Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Italian Delis & Bakeries in Brooklyn, New York

4.6 (930)

Category	Italian Delis & Bakeries
Address	185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Area	Brooklyn, New York
Google rating	4.6 (930)

Hours

Tuesday	12–7:30 PM
Wednesday	12–7:30 PM

About Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Family operated bakery specializing in key lime pies. Ours is a handmade product, using only fresh squeezed key limes, something that is rare even in the Florida Keys. We welcome walk-in customers at our Red Hook location: treat yourself to a fresh baked tart or whole pie available in two sizes. We also sell our Swingle™, our 4-inch tart hand dipped in rich Belcolade Belgian chocolate. We sell to some of NYC's finest eateries, from corner pubs to the best steakhouses. We pride ourselvs in delivering a fresh-baked product, whether at our storefront, restaurant or retailer. Banquets and events can arrange to have fresh squeezed, fresh baked key lime pies and tarts delivered fresh the day of the event. We have ALL the Keys... to a Great Pie©.

Is this your business? Claim this listing to update details, add photos and get a verified badge; every verified claim gives $1 to charity. Want more customers? Feature it at the top of italian delis & bakeries in Brooklyn.

Latest Google reviews

The 5 most recent reviews shown on Google Maps. Reviews belong to their authors; read all of them on Google.

Terrence A. a month ago

If you like a legit key lime pie, this is where to go to get some. You get several options of how to get your key lime fix. I’d recommend either the regular pies themselves or the chocolate dipped ones on the stick. I saw five kids sharing a whole pie with forks yesterday and that’s the exact vibe this place has.

Sean 2 months ago

Really yummy! The frozen pie with chocolate and raspberry is an awesome combo of flavors. Great for a warm day. Come here if you’re craving that sort of thing!

Fred M 2 months ago

Amazingly good Key Lime Pie in various sizes potentialy accompanied with home made limonade from lime you can not find anywhere else miles around. Truly delicious and one of a kind experience in Brooklyn. Special sweet taste of the dough with sour taste of the lime is one of kind. Truly worth the special trip to the area.

Yuki Cohen 2 months ago

Wow!!! My BF recommended this place for their super fresh limes used on these tarts! Yum yum yum!! Don’t miss it! Take a walk on the nearby boardwalk with some of the best views with a tart! Heaven on earth!

Anushka Sanil 3 months ago

As a key lime pie lover this hit the spot! In addition to classic key lime, they have other variations like raspberry and even a spicy chipotle one. We went with the classic swingle which was delicious and exactly what you’d expect. The dipped chocolate is a great elevation to already delicious pie. The perfect sweet treat!

All reviews on Google ↗

Frequently asked questions

Where is Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie located?

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is at 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, in Brooklyn, New York. Use the “Open in Google Maps” button on this page for directions.

What kind of business is Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie?

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is listed as an italian deli.

What are the hours of Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie?

Published hours are Tuesday: 12–7:30 PM; Wednesday: 12–7:30 PM. Hours can change on holidays, so call before a special trip.

How is Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie rated on Google?

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie has a Google rating of 4.6 out of 5 from 930 reviews.

Does Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie have a website?

Yes, the website of Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is keylime.com (linked on this page).

Are there other italian delis & bakeries near Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie?

Yes. Brooklyn also has Caputo's Fine Foods, Cait's Key Lime, Mia's Brooklyn Bakery among others; see the full list of italian delis & bakeries in Brooklyn at the bottom of this page.